Monday, March 22, 2010

"The Great Stone Death"

When John D MacDonald was asked by Stephen King to write an Introduction for his 1978 collection of short stories Night Shift, MacDonald responded with an interesting, at times belligerent piece about the mechanics of writing. While praising King and deploring the large majority of popular authors -- "...household names who have never really bothered to learn their craft" -- he made two observations about the field of writing King specialized in. His first was a kind of backhanded compliment toward King which disparaged the horror field:

"... I do not give a diddly-whoop what Stephen King chooses as an area in which to write. The fact that he presently enjoys writing in a field of spooks and spells and slitherings in the cellar is to me the least important and useful fact about the man anyone can relate."

The second was a more direct aphorism about the field in general:

"Two of the most difficult areas to write in are humor and the occult. In clumsy hands the humor turns to dirge and the occult turns funny."

MacDonald does not reveal that he himself once tried writing horror, way back at the beginning of his career when he was churning out short stories for the pulps. He had two tales printed in the most famous of all horror pulps, Weird Tales, both published in early 1949 and both largely forgotten. The first of those stories, "The Great Stone Death," originally published in the January 1949 issue, has recently been anthologized in the 2010 eBook Death Quotient and Other Stories, and using MacDonald's own rules as outlined in the Night Shift Introduction, we can be thankful that it was not a field the author pursued afterward.

The story reads like any tale a reader could have easily found in one of the pre-code horror comic books of the era (I was particularly reminded of "The Thing With the Golden Hair."). Two men on horseback are riding along a trail deep in the wilderness of the Sangre de Cristo Mountains. John Logan has been persuaded by his companion Steve Fowler to take this camping trip in order to have John "learn the country." He's recently relocated to the American Southwest because of a lung problem, but has spent most of his time in a hotel bar, gazing out at the mountains with "a kind of sneering look." This bothered Steve, a local who has spent a lot of time in the mountains, and he eventually convinces Logan to make the trip.

Logan is regretting his decision. His horse has thrown him once already and he has a perpetual feeling of unease about the wilderness, "...as though some grim spirit crouched back in the blue shadows and silently watched their progress with an enigmatic smile." He is a city boy and takes comfort in the safety of a place "where he could protect himself." He views Steve as a guileless simpleton with no imagination. When the two make camp for the night, Logan reveals his fears to Steve, who laughs them off.

Logan: "There are thousands of square miles that have never been seen by man. Actually, they are the same as they were back in the dawn of history. Who knows what you might run across up in these hills."

Steve: "The great stone lizard, maybe?"

Logan: "What's that?"

Steve: "Oh, foolish Indian talk. Their old men talk about some great stone lizard that lives up above the timberline. Been up here for centuries, the way they tell it."

Logan: "It could be."

Steve: "Hell, man! You beginning to sound like the Indians."

When Steve compares his own feelings about New York City to Logan's fear of the wilderness, the uneasiness subsides, but only until Steve drifts off to sleep. Then Logan lies there awake:

"... he looked up at the unwinking stars and the roar of the stream seemed to be whispering something to him in hoarse, damp words. Words he couldn't quite understand. He huddled down deeper in the bedroll and licked dry lips. Far off in the pine forest something screamed in distant, futile horror. The sound sent feathers of ice crawling up his spine. Deadly is the long night."

By morning his fears had lessened and the two enjoy breakfast before heading out again... to a place far up above the timberline...

"The Great Stone Death" is a relatively short work of 3,600 words that is as predictable as it is derivative. MacDonald obviously has no love or appreciation of of the horror genre and the tale reads like a well-done pastiche, which it probably was. It is usually classified along with his other science fiction works simply because something impossible happens, but it reads with a kind of detached air that tells me the author really wasn't interested in what he was doing. It's not poorly written or uninteresting, it just doesn't leave the reader with the sense of wonder and place that his other s-f stories do.

Yet the JDM fan should be happy to see it republished, even if it's only in eBook form. Unfortunately I'm discovering that Death Quotient and Other Stories is marred by more than a few typographical errors, usually the kind that pass a spell-check but are actually the wrong words. Nowhere is this more unfortunate than in "The Great Stone Death," where the last word in the story is almost certainly in error and possibly spoils a surprise ending. Having no access to the original, I can only speculate.


Friday, March 19, 2010

"Elimination Race"

I mentioned in an earlier post that John D MacDonald was a prolific producer of sports fiction, that he wrote at least 29 such stories in the early days of his writing career, and that most of these stories were written for now-forgotten pulps with names like Sports Fiction and Super Sports. Those old pulp magazines are some of the rarest and hard to find collectables around, and old issues rarely show up for sale on eBay. It seems like these were the most dispensable of fiction magazines and were not collected with anything near the fanaticism of science fiction or, to a lesser extent, the mystery pulps. I own one story from the sports pulps -- "Blue Water Fury" -- and that's only because MacDonald included it in his first short story collection End of the Tiger and Other Stories under the title "The Big Blue." The two previous sports tales I've written about came from a men's magazine and a Sunday newspaper supplement, and "Elimination Race" will be no exception: It was printed in the most mainstream of mainstream slicks, Collier's.

Appearing in the magazine's September 13, 1952 issue, "Elimination Race" is all about auto racing. Wade Ralson is a middle-aged race car driver with a wife and kids. His day job is running a small garage, but he's an experienced racer with twelve appearances in the Indianapolis 500. He trying to arrange a car to enter in his thirteenth appearance but is having trouble. His problem is he's never won. He came in third once, then fourth another time, and those were his best results. Last year he crashed and burned. He feels he's simply the victim of bad luck and believes he still has a big win in him. But sponsors won't talk to him, and when he tells his wife Sally that he is looking for one, she reacts like a lot of racers' wives must:

"She dropped a dish in the sink and he heard it smash. She turned slowly and said, 'It isn't for you to decide. I saw you roll and burn, Wade. I saw it happen and I knew you were dead, because nobody could live through that, and I was sure you were dead. And I sat by your bed all those weeks while they were doing the grafts and giving you the plasma. So you can't say I ever backed out before. All the stinking wrecks and the clunker heaps you drove, and that smash at Cleveland and over the rail in Miami...I won't stop you. I know that. But I won't be there. I won't even let myself think about it. And if you come back, maybe we can make some kind of life, but it won't ever be the same again. Ever, ever, ever.'"
Whoa......

All Sally manages to do is leave Wade with a sense of "righteous anger" and a determination to race. "One more time. One more chance to show them all." He continues looking and Sally doesn't bring up the subject again. Eventually there is no one else to ask. No one but that man Oliver Banderson down in Florida, who tells Wade over the phone, "I can't promise anything, but come on down if you can, and we'll talk it over."

"It was a bad thing dealing with Banderson, because there was something strange about him. He's put the money into the big cars, and money into the drivers, and it never seemed to mean much to him except the power-sense, the indirect way of killing a man. He got good drivers and they would work with him once and never again."

Wade goes down to Florida anyway and meets Banderson at his lavish Gulf-front beach house. He's a familiar MacDonald "type":

"He was a crisp little elderly man with a mocking smile and a faint and disconcerting slant of his eye, so that it was difficult to look directly at him and make any guess at what he might be thinking."

Wade makes his pitch but Banderson isn't biting. He tells Wade that he is entering one car in the Indy 500 and that he's using Johnny Harvester as driver. He offers Wade $200 to cover his expenses in coming down, and tells him to enjoy his drink and to stay around for a party he is throwing. Wade tears up the money and throws it into the pool, but he does hang around for the bash.

Johnny Harvester arrives, along with a crowd of "kids," teenagers who love cars and love to race. Wade drinks too much and ends up with one of the girls on his arm, a "lean young girl with taffy hair and bold, undisciplined eyes." After dinner everyone piles into cars and heads for Banderson's local track, where he races stock cars. A couple of the party boys were supposed to be driving two of Banderson's cars that night, but they are too smashed to get behind the wheels. Banderson then makes an offer, one it seems the whole evening was leading up to: Wade and Harvester will substitute for the two drunk boys, and whoever wins will drive Banderson's car in the 500.

There is a long, exciting race that ends with a predictable result, and Wade finally realizes something about himself he didn't know before.

MacDonald writes about racing the way he writes about everything: with the knowledge and confidence of an expert. As far as I know he was never a fan of auto racing and did not harbor a lot of love for the automobile in particular. In 1971 he wrote, "I really do not care that much about cars. If they go from here to there without drawing undue attention to themselves because of failure to perform properly, that is all I ask." Still, in "Elimination Race" he manages to convey the world of racing and the particular psyche of the driver with the same insight he did everything else.

The story was anthologized once, in a 1963 collection titled High Gear, edited by Evan Jones. It is tough to locate and the collector would probably have an easier time finding a copy of the original Collier's.

Thursday, March 18, 2010

"Oh, Give Me a Hearse!" ("A Place to Live")

One of the certainties when writing for the pulp magazines of the Thirties, Forties or Fifties was the unhappy fact that the author's original title rarely survived. A review of the stories John D MacDonald sold to pulps such as Dime Detective, Detective Tales or Doc Savage reveals that nearly every single submission was published under a new title. MacDonald's weighty, sometimes overly-serious appellations such as "A Stage for Dying," "All the Dead Brothers" or "Never in This World" gave way to more marketable titles like "Hot-Seat on the Aisle," "College-Cut Kill" and "Worse Than Murder." It was the magazine editors' job to sell issues, after all, not to try and please the authors -- who were usually pleased enough with a sale and could have cared less what their stories were called.

A favorite title-type was the punning variation on a popular phrase, song title or book, and some of these were singularly inventive and amusing. A few of the better ones printed over JDM's name are "Finders Killers," "Cash on the Coffin," "The Lady is a Corpse," "I'll Drown You in My Dreams," and my favorite, "Yes, Sir, That's My Slay-Babe!"

When MacDonald submitted a 5,400-word crime story he called "A Place to Live," to Dime Detective in 1947, he had to have known that the title was far too tame to survive, and sure enough when the story was published in the October issue it was called "Oh, Give Me a Hearse!" There is no hearse in the story, but hey, why throw away a good title? No matter what you call it, it's still one of JDM's better efforts from the very early period of his writing career. He liked it enough to have it included in his 1984 pulp anthology, More Good Old Stuff, and he almost certainly felt a strong sense of satisfaction when he restored his original title.

The setting is a town called Amberton, most likely a stand-in for one of the many cities in the Mohawk Valley where the MacDonalds lived. It's a town that is slowly dying, stuck in the grip of crooked politicians, uncaring citizens, and an ex-brewer political boss who has everyone in his pocket.

"A taxi roared by, the springs and shocks smacking hard against the holes in the road. Holes in all the roads. Amberton was a stupid city. A fat, complacent, poorly run little city, full of bland, greedy politicians. The tax rate had climbed above fifty-five dollars a thousand, and factories stood idle along the river. New industry wouldn't come in... And still the politicians smiled, the citizens paid their taxes, the slum sections widened. The death of America...Right here in Amberton. And in the heart of every other fat little city where nobody cares -- but the politicians."

Bill Davo cares and he's going to do something about it. He's a junior city engineer who, after working in Amberton for two years has discovered a major pocket of corruption within the local government. A road contract has been awarded to a crooked firm and, thanks to a survey Davo has done, he has figured out how it's going to work. Every attempt to blow the whistle on it through his own boss and other higher-ups has been met with either silence or warnings for him to mind his own business. When Davo threatens to take the story to the public, he is framed, fired and beaten. His apartment is ransacked and he spends six days in bed recovering.

Through his girlfriend Jane Fay -- who also works for the city -- he has managed to get a copy of his original survey and takes it to the local newspaper. The editor, Johnson Vincens, is sympathetic but since the newspaper is owned by the town's political boss, he won't print it. He advises Davo to contact authorities at the state capital and spill the beans to them. As the story opens, Davo meets and tells everything to a man from the capital named Berman, but when Berman says something odd Davo becomes suspicious. Sure enough, someone in the state government alerted the city that Davo wanted to talk, and Berman is an imposter. He pulls a gun on Davo, they fight and Davo manages to tie up Berman and stick him in a hotel room closet.

Realizing he has a limited amount of time before Berman frees himself, he races over to Jane's apartment and tells her everything. It's late night by now, but they decide to ride over to editor Vincens' house and try and convince him once again. He relents and the three of them rush to the newspaper, write up a big exposé and manage to get it ready for that morning's edition. But Berman has freed himself and "the boys" arrive in time to stop any of the newspapers from being distributed. When Vincens attempts to interfere he is shot, Davo is arrested and Jane manages to sneak upstairs to Vincens office. While sitting in a jail cell Davo's only hope is that Jane made it to safety. Hours later, however, he sees Jane marching down the hall to the women's cell. All seems lost...


The background of corrupt city politics was an area where MacDonald had a bit of personal experience. In the Spring of 1946, after spending four months writing 800,000 rejected words, MacDonald had sold only one story. The $40 he received as payment was barely enough to repay some debt the family had incurred, let alone enough to support a family. He reluctantly went back to work, taking a job with the Utica Taxpayers' Research Bureau. He didn't last long there -- his stories soon began selling at a fairly rapid pace -- but he learned enough about the mechanics of city government to supply him with plenty of material. He used it in this story, in his 1952 tale "The Man from Limbo," and probably in other stories I haven't read yet. Its most notable use was as background for his third novel Judge Me Not, where the hero has turned down a job for a similar taxpayer bureau in order to work as an assistant city manager.

"Oh, Give Me a Hearse!" is a better-than-average story from MacDonald's early period. Even though it contains what he called a "glib" ending, the writing is taut, the suspense well paced, and the details -- especially in the city jail -- are wonderfully realized. The problems he essayed have certainly not gone away in 60-plus years since the story was written, and his ruminations about the disintegration of rust belt industrial towns turned out to be quite perceptive and prescient.


Wednesday, March 17, 2010

"The Trouble with Erica"


I've never been sure exactly how to take "The Trouble with Erica." This 6,000-word John D MacDonald short story from the September 1953 issue of Cosmopolitan can be approached on a number of different levels and reveals, I think, a lot about MacDonald the Moralist. It's a troubling tale with an extremely disagreeable protagonist whose manipulation of friends and co-workers destroy a happy and promising relationship. The fact that he has subsequent doubts about his actions does little to assuage the bitter feeling the reader is left with, especially because one gets the sense that MacDonald enjoyed this ugly little trick almost as much as the protagonist did.


Mack Landers and his younger partner Quent Dale run a growing business that demands long hours and their full attention. But for the past six weeks Quent hasn't been "pulling full weight." He's met a girl and he's in love. Erica Holmes works in the city library and has just returned to town, homesick, after living for several years back east. Quent met her by chance and they began dating. Now, after only a month and a half, he wants to ask her to marry him.

This does not sit well with his partner. Landers, who is eight years Quent's senior and constantly refers to him as "kid," senses that this relationship will divert Quent's attention from work, and his dreams of growing their firm to mega-status will soon be replaced with just getting by. A double-date is arranged along with Mack's girl Marie and the story opens as they are dropping Erica back home. Mack, who is as obnoxious a character as any MacDonald had created up to that point, was surprised when he first saw Erica. He was expecting a "bloodless and bifocaled thing with elfin mannerisms," and instead he encountered a beautiful and alluring woman.

"... Erica had been a thing to stir the blood. Every time, during the evening, when she had been close to [Landers], the backs of [his] hands had tingled. She was a grave brunette, her hair so dark it looked almost blue under lights. She had tilted gray eyes, that husky voice, and a body suitable for a calendar in any repair shop. But it was more than that, he knew. It was a certain aura, an invisible emanation of desirability that could be felt ten feet away from her and increased in geometric proportion as he got closer..."
 
Mack suspects Erica is a woman with a past and worries that young, idealistic Quent has stars in his eyes and can't see that. Mack has been married, divorced, and seems to know a lot about certain "types" of women. When Quent reveals to Mack that he wants to ask Erica to marry him, Mack swings into action. He makes an unannounced mid-day visit to the library and confronts Erica obliquely ("... I just wanted to see you in your natural habitat...and maybe see how natural it is."), and fails to do anything but get her angry and defensive. He then comes up with an idea to go on another double date, this time a Sunday morning picnic. He arranges a last minute flat tire that allows him to drive to the picnic site with Erica, while Quent has to drive a bit later with the noxious Marie. Alone in the woods, Mack makes a play for Erica, who resists, or tries to, but like the scorpion riding on the back of the frog, cannot: it's her nature.

"He kissed her and then looked calmly at her face, looked at the glazed scimitar eyes, at the broken mouth. He laughed somewhere deep in his throat and took her in his arms again."


There are times when MacDonald's moralizing gets to be too much, never more so than when he is dealing with "fallen" or sexually active women. And although he has often treated them with extreme sympathy -- see Barbara Heddon in Judge Me Not, or Bonny Varaki in The Neon Jungle -- it is clear he only does so once they have redeemed themselves in his eyes. In Erica Holmes, MacDonald asks us to believe that a woman who is desperately attempting her own redemption will always be a slave to her uncontrollable desires and thus cannot be redeemed. It's self-defeating, it's holier-than-thou, and it is one of JDM's shortcomings that have led to many latter-day charges of sexism in his work.

Yet, in 1953 I doubt if MacDonald was worried about being called a sexist. His interest in "The Trouble with Erica" is not with the girl in the title, but the character and motivations of Mack Landers. A rude, brash know-it-all with no redeeming qualities, he prefigures the protagonists of some of MacDonald's "adult" stories in S*E*V*E*N such as Aldo Bellinger or Frank Raymond. He doesn't act out of spite or from some uncontrollable urge to make mischief, but because he honestly believes he is helping and doing the right thing. It is only at the end of the tale where we are allowed to see some possible uncertainty and even remorse on his part. I've often wondered if, in some sort of perverse way, MacDonald was modeling the character on himself.

"The Trouble with Erica" was anthologized once, in MacDonald's 1966 collection End of the Tiger and Other Stories.

(The interior magazine illustrations, by Arpie Ermoyan, came from Today's Inspiration.)

 

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

"Nothing Must Change"

Redbook is another one of today's woman's magazines that began life in a very different form. Like Cosmopolitan, it started out as a fiction magazine and underwent many different incarnations over the years. It was launched in 1903 as The Red Book Illustrated, later switching to The Red Book Magazine before finally becoming just Redbook in 1929. It was aimed at women, however, just as its sister publication Bluebook was aimed at men, and its early stories reflected that. It changed with the times and enjoyed periods of good, then shrinking, then recovered circulation and has managed to remain one of the few surviving periodicals that began life at the beginning of the last century. The list of authors published in Redbook over the years is a Who's Who of American fiction, including F. Scott Fitzgerald, Edith Wharton, Jack London and Edgar Rice Burroughs. Dashiell Hammett's final novel The Thin Man was serialized, not in Black Mask, but in Redbook in 1933, several months before it was published as a novel.

The current issue features articles such as "The Truth About Why Men Cheat," "How To Have Great Sex From A to Z" and "I Posed for (Very) Sexy Photos." Yes, times have changed.

John D MacDonald wrote five short stories that were published in Redbook, as well as two novels that were published before they came out in book form: Murder in the Wind (published as "Hurricane"), and The Deceivers, which was titled "The Faithless." His very first story to appear in the magazine was something called "Nothing Must Change," and it was included in the June 1951 issue. And, yes, its a "woman's" story, told from a woman's point of view and it is a good example of MacDonald's life as a mainstream author. I'm sure that readers of Murder for the Bride, which came out in paperback the same month that this story was published, would not have believed you if you told them the two works were by the same author. It is just another testament to JDM's skill, versatility and growing confidence as a writer of fiction.

In 1951 the MacDonald family had just moved from Clearwater to a beach cottage on a still-fairly-undeveloped Casey Key in Florida. It is just such a setting where "Nothing Must Change" takes place, a little "fantastic shack" on the Gulf Coast, occupied by Max and Carol Cheventza. Max is a twenty-five year old painter, still in the process of finding himself in his art, while Carol is his thirty-three year old wife. Max is Carol's second husband; her first husband Charles died several years ago and Carol remarried quickly thereafter. Carol was left with enough money to support the two of them as Max pursues a hoped-for career as a painter.The back room of the "shack" has been converted into a large studio, and it is here that Max spends weeks as he works in feverish concentration on one of his works.

Max has just come out of one of those three-week zones and is excited to show Carol his painting. Carol, as she always has to do, holds her breath and goes back to witness the grand creation. The problem? Max isn't very good. Carol is afraid to say anything and has to feign appreciation every time Max completes another one. "If she had dared to criticize it aloud, she would say, 'It's too big and bright and harsh and ugly and... I don't understand it.'" Instead, she says what she always says: "It's nice." But Max apparently can't see his own shortcomings.

"She thought it most odd that Max should have such a blind spot. And she knew that she was not wrong. The modern schools were no mystery to her. Subjective art did not appall her, and she could look at formlessness in an unselfconscious attempt to find decorativeness without implication. But Max's work, with the ripened flesh of flowers, or gray stumps in a harsh chrome-yellow sea, with backgrounds like flashlight rays converging on swamp grasses -- it was not representational, nor subjective, nor anything classifiable. It simply made her feel tense and confused and oddly frightened."

Luckily, Max's shortcomings as a painter are the only problem in this marriage. Otherwise Max is a tender, dutiful and attentive husband, full of energy, humor and youthful enthusiasm. But then trouble arrives in the form of a letter. Carol's college roommate, Greta Lasson, has written, announcing that she will be in the area soon and wants to stop by. Carol is frozen with fear, but not Max.

"'Lasson!' he said. 'Greta Lasson. Where have I heard that name? Don't tell me.' He snapped his fingers. 'Articles. She writes about painters and paintings. Criticisms of shows. She's big time.'"

Max quickly deduces that Greta is really coming down to check up on Carol, to make sure she hasn't gotten herself into an impossible situation with a supposedly wild, young, unscrupulous confidence man who is living off of her money. Carol is worried about something else altogether: the terrible blow to Max's youthful confidence once an art critic gets an eyeful of the junk Max had been painting. Perhaps it would be for the best, to have an honest impression deliver a dose of reality to her husband. But she obviously does not want to see Max's spirit crushed. His intensity has made Carol feel years younger, her figure trimmer, her face younger, and she has largely forgotten the difference in their ages. She does not want to lose that.

The letter took its time arriving, and Greta is scheduled to arrive... today! Carol has no time to prepare.


"Nothing Must Change" is an enjoyable and engaging story that works on a lot of different levels. On one hand, it is a straightforward telling of an unequal relationship and how a third party disrupts that relationship. There is the subtext of the age difference, the ghost of a dead husband, secrets kept between lovers, and how a dose of reality might upset the creative process and, ultimately, the marriage. On another level, for those readers of JDM who are familiar with his biography, the story resonates with a lot of interesting and recognizable characteristics. Dorothy MacDonald was herself a painter, not simply the wife of a highly creative husband who sought her own creative outlet, but someone whose artistic inclinations were expressed long before her husband's were. Like Carol, she was older than her husband (by five years, not eight) and had been married previously. And as mentioned above, the location bears a striking resemblance to the place the author was living when the story was written.

Yet perhaps most interesting of all is MacDonald's description of the creative process, and how periods of intense artistic focus are times of loneliness and separation for the "non-creative" partner.The story opens at noon, with Carol awake and hearing the sounds of Max awakening in the bedroom. As she listens she holds the handle of a dish mop "so tight that her fingers hurt." Max, we learn, hadn't come to bed until dawn was already breaking. She looks at the face of her awakening husband and saw "the face of a stranger."

"Three weeks; this time the cool-eyed, quiet withdrawal had lasted longer."

What the reader initially suspects to be the aftermath of an affair turns out to be a three-week rush of creativity as Max began and finished another painting. I wondered when reading the story if this wasn't MacDonald putting himself in the place of his wife during the intense years of early writing when beginning his career. He wrote 800,000 words before selling a single story ("Interlude in India" excepted) and produced over 175 sold pieces of short fiction in the space of three and a half years. Wife Dorothy must have spent a lot of time by herself during those years, painting or no painting. And I suppose that being married to an artist can seem at times like being the witness to an affair, as the passion and the tunnel vision of creativity excludes all outside interference.

Perhaps because his wife was a painter, MacDonald knew a lot about art and wrote about it confidently. Like his character Carol Cheventza, the "modern schools" were no mystery to him. In 1959 he wrote a novel about an artists' colony in Mexico titled Please Write for Details, where he exhibits a deep understanding of art, modern art and the peculiar characteristics of the artists themselves. While JDM could appreciate what was then called "modern art," he had no patience with the poseurs who created such abstractions as a mask for the lack of any real talent. One of MacDonald's favorite scenes, written originally in Please Write for Details and repeated years later in a Travis McGee novel (I think it was Indigo), has one of these "modernists" challenged to draw a simple picture of a horse. Of course, they can't, but when it comes to slopping large amounts of bright paint on a blank canvas, they are considered "great artists."

"Nothing Must Change" appeared in print only once and has never been anthologized.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Area of Suspicion

Area of Suspicion was John D MacDonald's eleventh novel, published in February of 1954. Up to that point all of MacDonald's paperback originals had been published by Fawcett Gold Medal, but Area of Suspicion appeared as a Dell First Edition, the twelfth in that series. According to Hugh Merrill in The Red Hot Typewriter, MacDonald was having a "personality conflict" with Fawcett editor Dick Carroll and jumped ship to Dell and into the open arms of Knox Burger. Burger had been the fiction editor of Collier's in 1949 and was responsible for the author's first four-figure payment, for the delightful "Looie Follows Me," and the two had remained in contact. When Burger joined Dell it was only a matter of time before JDM would join him there, and although MacDonald still owed one more book to Fawcett (All These Condemned, which came out in September), his next eleven paperback originals alternated between Dell and Popular Library. In 1958 Burger joined Fawcett and MacDonald moved with him again, delivering Clemmie as his first Fawcett Gold Medal release in four years.

Area of Suspicion is an odd and unique entry in the JDM cannon. It began life in early 1952 as a serialized novel titled "My Brother's Widow" and was published in five consecutive issues of Collier's. Very soon after publication the author began expanding the work to novel length, under the working title Threat of Storm. By May of 1953 he had changed it to Area of Suspicion and told the Sarasota Herald-Tribune, "This is a tiresome job. You see, I know how the [story] ends." Dell published a relatively large run of the book (750,000 copies) and there was never enough demand to print a subsequent edition. In 1961 Fawcett published the "First Gold Medal printing" in an edition "specially revised by the author." It is that edition that saw life in over a dozen new printings through 1987.

So, depending on how dedicated a JDM collector you are, you can read three versions of this same story.

It is also MacDonald's first "business" novel, that unique genre of JDM tales that deal with a hero who is a member of upper management in industrial America. He would expand on this theme, producing far better books, in Contrary Pleasure, The Deceivers, Clemmie and A Man of Affairs, to name the most obvious. Yet Area of Suspicion draws on a unique segment of industry, the military armament sector, as it was a field where the author had much personal experience. From 1940 to 1943 he served in the US Army as an ordnance inspector, first in Rochester and later in Schenectady before shipping out to Asia during World War II. The setting for the novel is obviously one of those two locations, or perhaps Utica, for the place descriptions ring with a telling authenticity. Still, the plot is a potboiler and the book enjoys a mixed reputation, at best.

Told in first person, Area of Suspicion begins on the west coast of Florida(!) and our hero is one Gevan Dean, "...sun-darkened... to the shade of waxed mahogany, hair and eyebrows bleached lighter than [his] skin." Gevan is beginning year five of an early retirement and living off the dividends from his large share of stock in Dean Products, a family business begun by his grandfather and a business he ran before coming to Florida. Gev seems to have it made, with parties every night, his pick of the "little sun-tanned beach girls," and not a care in the world. But lately he has begun to feel the "vague, unwelcome stirrings of discontent."

"Mine was the Great American Dream achieved. Money and idleness. But with it had come a sense of guilt, as though I were accused of some unspecified crime. And I guessed that my playmates, when they were alone, felt the same way. Hence our perpetual and turbulent parties. It was as though we had all begun to have a faint aroma of decay. The world was spinning toward some unthinkable destination, and we sat in the sand with our buckets and castles."


Trouble arrives in the form of a visitor, an old associate from his hometown of Arland, informing Gev that his younger brother Ken has died, shot outside his home by an unknown assailant. Lester Fitch has flown down to Florida because Gev wasn't answering his phone. He's already missed the funeral and Fitch has brought some paperwork along with him, including a voting proxy for Gev's 8,000 shares of Dean Products stock. Through an interior monologue we learn that Gevan's Florida retirement is not as simple as it seems. Five years ago he was engaged to be married, to a young secretary who worked at Dean named Niki Webb, but a few weeks before the scheduled marriage, Gevan walked in on Niki and his brother Ken. Gevan attempts to justify what has essentially been a four-year pout:

"... I found out that I could not go on. I couldn't adjust myself to the role of the betrayed, the strong silent type who contents himself with Job alone now that Girl is gone. I might have managed it if it had been someone else who had taken her from me. But Ken and I had been close... my brother had stolen the satisfaction of my work in the same moment he had stolen Niki Webb."

Fitch, who Gevan has known since childhood and had never liked or respected, seems just a bit too anxious to have Gev sign the proxy. His suspicions aroused, Gev decides to return north and vote in the upcoming shareholders' meeting. At stake is the control of Dean Products, a contest between old-timer Walter Granby, the company treasurer who has been around forever, and a relative newcomer, corporate hotshot Stanley Mottling. With the battle lines drawn, it seems that Gev's shares represent the swing vote. But returning to Arland means revisiting a lot of ghosts and, undoubtedly, facing Niki once again.

And face her he does. Niki, the grieving widow, seems far too interested in rekindling their romance, and Gev seems incapable of resisting her charms. Of all the improbabilities in Area of Suspicion (and there are a lot) this one reaches the farthest, as we are asked to believe that a man who has just spent four years partying and bedding probably hundreds of beach bunnies is incapable of resisting a woman who wounded him so deeply. On his first visit to the house they kiss, and on the second well... applying sunscreen was never so erotic.

Gevan soon sees there's more going on at Dean Products than a classic power struggle between old guard and new blood. Niki has inherited Ken's block of stock and has developed a sudden interest in making sure that Stanley Mottling stays in power. The company has received a major government contract to build super-secret weaponry and the Pentagon has installed an onsite contracting officer, a Colonel Dolson, who also seems to have some sort of proprietary interest in keeping Mottling. And of course there was Fitch and the voting proxy. There is an air of wariness and resignation among the old guard of employees who were there when Gev ran the place. In the words of one, "There's a smell around [Dean Products]. Like something crawled under the buildings and died."

After a visit to the police and a talk with the murder suspect, Gevan makes a call on the suspect's girlfriend. Suspicions are aroused about the official story. He decides to poke around the plant and enlists the aid of his former secretary Joan Perrit. Joan is a classic MacDonald "type," the once gawky, painfully-shy-but incredibly efficient teenager who has now grown up to be a confidant, self-assured and still-single beauty. When Gev reminisces about Old Joan, the reader can immediately see that a relationship is going to develop:

"She was a sweet kid, with dark red hair and a look of virginal freshness. She was so loyal it was embarrassing. On the morning I dictated my letter of resignation, she had to leave the office. She was gone a full ten minutes, and when she came back her eyes were reddened and swollen, but her voice was level and calm again as she read back to me the last sentence I had dictated."

As Gev and Joan start looking around, strange things begin to happen. When another employee is found dead -- a girl who was working for and having an affair with Colonel Dolson -- the wild ride begins. People begin disappearing, a truck nearly knocks Gev's car off the road, and the police ultimately begin to believe that there may have been more to Ken's murder than they originally thought. The final fifty pages of the book are exciting, suspenseful and impossible to stop reading.

Taken on its own terms, Area of Suspicion is a fine work of thriller writing, with plenty of good characterization, expert detail and breathless suspense. MacDonald's background in ordnance contracting allows him to fill the pages of the book with all sorts of detailed descriptions of cost-plus government contracting, assembly-line mechanics, industrial techniques and the latest theories on methods of upper-level management. Gevan Dean is a Harvard Business School graduate, as was MacDonald, and the author's prior work in a factory just like Dean Products allows him to come up with a believable plot and a realistic method of sabotage.

But if we look at the book in light of MacDonald's progression as an artist, Area of Suspicion is not only an anomaly, it's a step backward. This is not surprising, given the nature of the story's beginnings as a serial, and the improbabilities in the plot have bothered more than one reviewer. One gets the sense in reading the novel that much of it was padded, especially in the overly-long interior monologues Gev engages in when fighting his desire for Niki. I've never read "His Brother's Widow," but I have a feeling that it is far better work, at least in the pacing.

Another aspect of the book may color the modern reader's impression, and that is the fact that the villains are communist agents.The story takes place during 1954 when the Cold War was being fought between two different sets of ideologies. Anything involving communist infiltration tends to be dismissed nowadays as unrealistic and the product of the Red Scare, as if the whole thing was made up to destroy good people's lives. The opening of the Soviet archives in the 1990's prove that the infiltration was all too real, but the US government's bulldozer method of dealing with the problem has left permanent scars, even as the people involved are largely no longer with us. I don't know... It's just a thought, but I wonder if the novel would be better remembered if the time period had been moved back to the war years, and the bad guys had been Nazis...

Like every John D MacDonald novel, there are passages of exceptional prose that ring musically and remain in the mind's eye. A few:

"There is a sickness in murder. It made a sickness in the city, and made me think, perversely, of the Gulf in pre-dawn grayness, the sudden hard strikes on the trolled lure, the dip of the rod tip, the singing of the reel, the breath-taking silver of the tarpon at the height of his leap. Later the sun would come up and the Gulf would be blue and the terns would dip and waver on the morning wind, white as bone, squabbling like picnic children. I had left all that and I had begun to walk along a narrow place."

"Among any group of chickens there is what the behavior specialists call 'the pecking order.' Put any batch of chickens together, and within a day or so, after considerable bickering, they will work it out. It is a rigid social system. Chicken number eight can peck chicken number nine without fear of retaliation. And chicken number seven can peck just as freely at chicken number eight. And, in the order, should any chicken develop an illness, an unexpected weakness, the formal caste system will be suspended just long enough for all the others to peck it to death."

"So I took my brother's widow, violent, oiled and naked, squirming and thrusting on quilted white plastic on a redwood chaise on a walled fieldstone terrace in April sunshine, out of the wind, protected by all the formal stature of the dead man's home. It was without grace, dignity, tenderness or affection. It was like trapping in some narrow place something hard to kill, then killing it clumsily, violently, in fear and hate, with dreadful weapons, killing it as quickly as you can."

"Yes indeedy, off [Niki and I] would sail and in a couple of years we'd be able to speak fondly and tolerantly of good old Ken, and we'd be grateful to good old Stanley for keeping our dividends nice and fat. We'd just rove the blue seas and tie up at the fun places at the fashionable times, and make love, and drink too much, but always with adorable and enchanting people. And when the sex and sensation bit started to go a little dead, we could always give it a booster shot by taking exactly the right sort of couple on a little cruise, some adorable, enchanting pair too vulnerable to tell tales, and with some trading around and with some of the practices of the voyeur, we could put our romance right back on the up-beat, yes indeedy, and we would push the good old machine until finally the parts wore out, at which time the medics could gut her like a trout and carve away portions of me, and we would then want a larger and more comfortable boat and somebody to run it for us while we sat in adjoining deck chairs astern, soft, fat, brown as saddles, and without one bloody word left to say to each other or one itching thing to do to each other, yes indeedy. Bliss without end."

Prose like that, it's bliss without end.

As I've said, the reaction to the book was mixed, both then and now. Anthony Boucher in the New York Times gave JDM his first less-than-good review when the book was released, calling it "A long and often lifeless study of a battle for power in the management of an industrial plant... somewhat ponderous for a thriller..." A reviewer in the Norfolk Virginia Pilot slammed it as "... a routine thriller ... the characters, as usual, are cardboard." And more recently, in is excellent book Hardboiled America, Geoffrey O'Brien calls the book a "... startlingly banal anti-Communist thriller..."

Still, Area of Suspicion did have its defenders. The Lexington Leader called it "...edge-of-the-chair reading on a quiet night..." and the Columbus Citizen said it was "...one of his best...Don't start Area of Suspicion until you have the time to read it through without laying it down." When the British edition of the novel was published in 1956, the Daily Mail called the book "...a finely written novel of passion, crime, and retribution." And more recently, in their 1985 mystery study titled Private Eyes: One Hundred and One Knights, authors Robert Allen Baker and Michael T. Nietzel called Area of Suspicion a novel of "exceptional quality," proving that not every modern critic can become unhinged over the book's communist bad guys.

None of the four biographies of MacDonald bother to deal with the book in any substantive way.

The novel actually won an award back when it was published. The Mutual Broadcasting System awarded MacDonald a watch for "Best Mystery of the Month," proclaiming, "In recognition of his outstanding work as a writer of mystery and suspense stories whose literary efforts in the mystery writing field have enriched the American scene." I'll bet whoever wrote that proclamation never won an award for writing!

The cover art for the Dell First Edition, showing Gevan and Joan skulking around the outside of the Dean factory, was illustrated by Stanley Borak, the only JDM cover he ever produced. When Fawcett issued their own first edition it featured an alluring Niki lounging on red satin and wearing a very sheer negligee, illustrated by the great Barye Phillips. Another great illustrator, Robert McGinnis did the 1972 reprint, featuring an imagining of singer Hildy Devereaux (a character I didn't discuss). The 1997 version was another McGinnis illustration and it was used, in one form or another, in all subsequent printings.

The only copy of Area of Suspicion I own is the 1961 revision. It's tough to try and determine exactly to what extent MacDonald changed things, but I suspect it had more to do with the current events and science of the period rather than any artistic considerations. There is a lengthy scene where Gev is lecturing Jane on the ability of the United States and the USSR to wipe each other out with ICBMs, a technology the Soviets didn't possess until 1957. There are references to the revolutions in Cuba and the Congo which hadn't happened yet in 1954. Other than that I can't tell. There had been other "revisions" in the novels that were reprinted in the Sixties. In All These Condemned, for example, there is a reference to Marilyn Monroe in the past tense. Yet no other novel contained the cover blurb "Specially revised by the author," and it leads me to believe that the changes were more sweeping than what MacDonald typically did with subsequent printings.

And that, ultimately, may be the problem with Area of Suspicion, the fact that it has been tinkered with and worked over so much that it seems more like quilt work than an organically conceived novel. It's good, fun JDM but it's not the work of a novelist who was growing and learning with each successive work. Happily this would be the last time the author would return to an older work to try and change it into something different.


Friday, March 12, 2010

"Hit and Run" (1952)

For a guy who published around 400 works of short fiction during his career, John D MacDonald repeated himself fairly infrequently. I've caught a couple of instances where a short story was obviously modeled on one he had written previously, mainly occurring in the magazine This Week. Yet over a career that spanned 40 years, I can only find two short stories that bear the same title. This is amazing, considering that over half of MacDonald's titles were changed by magazine editors prior to publication. The repeated title is, of course, "Hit and Run." The first story bearing this name was originally published in the August 1952 issue of Good Housekeeping, while the second was published nearly ten years later in the September 16, 1961 issue of the Saturday Evening Post. This posting will discuss the original story.

MacDonald had only two stories published in Good Housekeeping. This "women's magazine" is another one of those you probably don't think of when you think of fiction, but a lot of famous authors were published within its pages over the years, including Daphne DuMaurier, Ray Bradbury and John Cheever. J. D. Salinger's 1948 short story "I Knew a Girl" originally appeared in Good Housekeeping. The August 1952 issue where "Hit and Run" was published features four new works of fiction, including one by Margaret Cousins, the magazine's Managing Editor! (I wonder how she got that one through?)

MacDonald's entry is a fairly straightforward criminal investigation story, showing off the author's detailed knowledge of police procedure. The title page announces it as "a story of suspense," yet there is no suspense here: a cop methodically tracks down a hit and run killer. What does make the story interesting is what MacDonald does with character, and how the crime he is investigating changes the policeman in charge of the investigation. I'm sure it's what "sold" the story to a magazine like Good Housekeeping and I doubt it would have been published here if it was simply another JDM "howdunit."

State trooper Del Carney is sitting in a small police substation somewhere west of Syracuse. A freak May snowstorm has made the late-night roads treacherous and he is finishing up an accident file involving a car full of teenagers. In comes his subordinate, Trooper Tillotson accompanying an attractive, well-dressed woman in her middle thirties. Tillotson found her nearly freezing to death in a parked car along Route 83, alone and with the engine off. The car had run out of gas and her husband left her there to walk down the road to the nearest station. It had been some time and he hadn't returned.

Carney has her sit by the warm stove and sends Tillotson back out to slowly trace the route from the car to the closest gas station. "Turn your spot on the ditch," he tells him. "Look for anything that might be a man covered up with snow." Realizing that he has alarmed the women, he apologizes. "We've got to think of a hit-and-run driver, or a heart attack."

The woman -- Linda Fairliss -- assures Carney that her husband, while nearly fifty years old, kept himself in top physical condition and could not have succumbed to a heart attack. Their marriage was a recent and happy one, and they were on their way to enjoy a vacation in Oregon. While Tillotson is back out looking, Carney does his best to keep Mrs. Fairliss' mind off the worst possibilities, but eventually runs out of questions and small talk. As he is working quietly on some paperwork, Linda gets up and looks out of the window, and for the first time we get a glimpse of Carney as a character with some subtext:

"When he glanced over, he saw that she had taken off her fur jacket and hung it on the back of the chair... It was a nice tweed suit, he decided. And she had that square-shouldered, trim-hipped, long-waisted look that made clothes look good... She was looking at him with polite attention, and he felt a sudden unreasoning jealousy at this Fairliss, who at -- what was it? -- forty-seven had found this woman and married her. It had been a long time since he had felt jealousy toward any man."

Then, at half-past twelve, the phone rings and the bad news is delivered: Peter Fairliss has been found dead on the side of the highway, and it appears to be a hit-and-run. Carney hangs up and faces Linda Fairliss, who already knows what he is going to say. He thinks to himself:

"Usually it happens over the phone; that was easier because you couldn't see their faces. The expression on this woman's face startled him. He was not easily moved by looks of anger; he had seen the lusterless animal eyes of the psychotic killer-type. This was cold, intellectual ferocity, glistening. 'Hit and run, Sergeant? I want him caught. I want to look at him.'"

Then Carney does something he has never done before, and he realizes his stupidity as soon as it's done: he promises her he will find the driver.

The next day Carney begins his investigation and Linda Fairliss returns home. Based on the evidence at the scene, it appears that a car came around a curve, slid and hit Peter Fairliss with the rear side of the car. The police are able to get some paint scrapings that later point to the vehicle being a 1936 Ford. Carney proceeds dutifully, checking county registration records for the current year, then state records, and when that brings nothing he goes back a year, then another. At one point his superior officer tells him to drop the case, but Carney asks if it would be okay to nose around on his days off.

"What's your stake in this?" asks his boss.

"This one got me a little."

And on it goes... In typical MacDonald fashion, the protagonist makes a leap of logic, hunts around in some unlikely places and... there it is. "Hit and Run" would be just another version of "The Homesick Buick" if the author hadn't made Carney such an interesting guy. He's fleshed out nicely, with an economy of words and actions, and the development of his character becomes just as interesting as the developments in the case. At certain steps along the way, he pauses to briefly ruminate on his motivations. Before going home Linda asks Carney, "Are you going to work on the case?" and Carney "did not understand why he should flush at that question...

"He felt a mild irritation that he had condemned himself to pounding around the countryside. Quixotic, he thought, that's me. You figure you're old enough and practiced enough and bored enough to be at last forever beyond the reach of any puerile self-identification with the maimed and lost, the casualties of four-lane civilization. And then one sneaks up on you. Linda Fairliss, widow. Thirty-six. Not young, not old."

The "eureka!" moment is a brilliantly done few sentences that not only advances the plot, it defines the loneliness of the character and provides a neat little metaphor for Sergeant Carney's solitude and motivation:

"An idea nibbled at the edge of his mind. He turned on the light and sat on the edge of the bed -- a precaution against falling asleep before the idea was fully developed. It was a trick he hadn't used for a long time. Not since he had been a young instructor at the State university. Before Chris and the stillborn child had shared a common grave. Before he had so arbitrarily selected a calling as remote as possible from the world that reminded him of Chris... When you want to hide something, you either hide it where it will not be seen at all or you hide it where it will be seen but not noticed..."

"Hit and Run" is a satisfying, well-written story that leads to unexpected places, a story that in the hands of a good writer resonates and stays with you long after you've finished reading it. And while the author's 1961 story titled "Hit and Run" has been anthologized over a half dozen times, this story has never been republished. It's a shame.

And, in case you're wondering, the cover of this particular issue of Good Housekeeping is not an illustration from the story!